2004 Col Solare

92 pts - Wine Enthusiast
91 pts - Wine Spectator
Editor's Choice - "This new release from the high-profile Ste. Michelle/Antinori Red Mountain project may be the finest Col Solare to date."

2003 Col Solare

94 pts - Wine Advocate
90 pts - Wine Spectator

2002 Col Solare

94 pts - The Wine Advocate
90 pts - Wine Spectator

2001 Col Solare

91 pts - Wine Spectator
90 pts - Wine & Spirits
90 pts - The Wine Advocate

1999 Col Solare

92 pts - Wine Enthusiast
91 pts - The Wine Advocate

1998 Col Solare

92 pts - Wine Spectator
91 pts - Connoisseurs' Guide

1997 Col Solare

92 pts - Connoisseurs' Guide
90 pts - California Grapevine
90 pts - International Wine Cellar
90 pts - Wine Spectator
Four Stars - Restaurant Wine

1996 Col Solare

92 pts - Wine Spectator

1995 Col Solare

Four Stars - Restaurant Wine